Costello Catholic References
Costello Catholic References
Ursula writes to listserv -
The book Complicated Shadows touched briefly on the influence that
Costello's Catholicism has had on his life/lyrics. As a self-professed
"Lapsed Catholic (see liner notes to Fairfield Four CD), Costello seems to
still see himself as a "Cultural Catholic" (refering to himself "as a
Catholic" on the recent Kumars at 42 episode and in his boycott of the
Sinead O'Connor appearance as covered in the latest biography).
There are far too many "Catholic References" in his lyrics to list them
all (an entire book could be written on how the imagery invades his
lyrical choices), but even if you don't count each reference to "I bless,"
and "Angel(s)," a short list would include:
From the new "Secret Songs"
"How deep was the red our REDEEMER bled"
Couldn't Call it Unexpected #4
"she said one day my PRINCE OF PEACE will come"
All This Useless Beauty
"GOOD FRIDAY arrived, the sky darkened on time"
Human Hands
"All I ever want is to fall into your HUMAN HANDS"
(Offertory Prayer at Mass: "Fruit of the vine, work of Human Hands")
Pump It Up
"No use wishing now for any other SINâ€
The book Complicated Shadows touched briefly on the influence that
Costello's Catholicism has had on his life/lyrics. As a self-professed
"Lapsed Catholic (see liner notes to Fairfield Four CD), Costello seems to
still see himself as a "Cultural Catholic" (refering to himself "as a
Catholic" on the recent Kumars at 42 episode and in his boycott of the
Sinead O'Connor appearance as covered in the latest biography).
There are far too many "Catholic References" in his lyrics to list them
all (an entire book could be written on how the imagery invades his
lyrical choices), but even if you don't count each reference to "I bless,"
and "Angel(s)," a short list would include:
From the new "Secret Songs"
"How deep was the red our REDEEMER bled"
Couldn't Call it Unexpected #4
"she said one day my PRINCE OF PEACE will come"
All This Useless Beauty
"GOOD FRIDAY arrived, the sky darkened on time"
Human Hands
"All I ever want is to fall into your HUMAN HANDS"
(Offertory Prayer at Mass: "Fruit of the vine, work of Human Hands")
Pump It Up
"No use wishing now for any other SINâ€
Ursula adds -
Just reminded of a GOOD ONE from The Delivery Man's NEEDLE TIME:
"I wish I could be just like a SAINT is, and forgive those who trespass
against us."
That's a double! From the "Our Father" (Forgive us our sins as we
forgive those who trespass against us).
From "The Delivery Man"
"Suffer little children" (another amazing Bible gloss - "And Jesus said
suffer the little children . . ")
Incredible . . .
Just reminded of a GOOD ONE from The Delivery Man's NEEDLE TIME:
"I wish I could be just like a SAINT is, and forgive those who trespass
against us."
That's a double! From the "Our Father" (Forgive us our sins as we
forgive those who trespass against us).
From "The Delivery Man"
"Suffer little children" (another amazing Bible gloss - "And Jesus said
suffer the little children . . ")
Incredible . . .
-
- Posts: 2228
- Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 2:20 pm
- Location: Poland
After The Elvis Costello Home Page :
Little Atoms - contains several biblical references from 1 Corinthians 13:
"When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought
as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things."
"And now abideth faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of
these is charity."
"Betraying with a kiss" has also obvious associations.
Little Atoms - contains several biblical references from 1 Corinthians 13:
"When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought
as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things."
"And now abideth faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of
these is charity."
"Betraying with a kiss" has also obvious associations.
If you don't know what is wrong with me
Then you don't know what you've missed
Then you don't know what you've missed
More from listserv -
From Little Palaces:
"In the arms of John the Pope"
From "Put You Big Foot In The Milk of Human Kindness"
"Virgin Mary"
(of course the cheeky "10 Bloody Marys & 10 How's Your Fathers" as a
spoof on a typical "penance")
But real discovery is the entire song he wrote for Italian Pop
Superstar Zuccherro. Remember the song "MISS MARY" which was dripping with
exclusively Catholic references to Mary:
"I wish your were my Queen" (Mary is called "Queen of Heaven" by
Catholics)
"Jerome" (St. Jerome is held as the first person to translate the bible
into Latin)
"Heavenly Vision"
"Magdalena"
But the kicker is the beautiful description of a typical side altar for
Mary that you would see in virtually any Catholic Church:
"Veined steps of marble/purple, gold and green."
(not unlike the one that a young "Veronica" is seen praying the Rosary
to in the flashback sequence of the Music Video for "Veronica")
On the song LONG JOURNEY HOME, Costello virtually nicks the TUNE from a
traditional Catholic Hymn that he would have sung as an Altar Boy
growing up. The song is called "O Queen of the Holy Rosary" and note the
lyrics:
O Queen of the Holy Rosary,
O bless us as we pray,
And offer thee our roses
In garlands day by day,
While from our Father's garden,
With loving hearts and bold,
We gather to thine honor
Buds white and red and gold.
Compare the line in Long Journey Home:
"Red white and blue, green white and gold" to the same tune and you
have a virtual GLOSS on the Catholic Hymn.
Not to mention "Miss Mary"'s "Purple, Gold and Green" line.
Costello is a virtual treasure trove of Traditional Catholic influences
that at the very least INFORM his lyrics.
Yours in Christ,
Ursula!
From Little Palaces:
"In the arms of John the Pope"
From "Put You Big Foot In The Milk of Human Kindness"
"Virgin Mary"
(of course the cheeky "10 Bloody Marys & 10 How's Your Fathers" as a
spoof on a typical "penance")
But real discovery is the entire song he wrote for Italian Pop
Superstar Zuccherro. Remember the song "MISS MARY" which was dripping with
exclusively Catholic references to Mary:
"I wish your were my Queen" (Mary is called "Queen of Heaven" by
Catholics)
"Jerome" (St. Jerome is held as the first person to translate the bible
into Latin)
"Heavenly Vision"
"Magdalena"
But the kicker is the beautiful description of a typical side altar for
Mary that you would see in virtually any Catholic Church:
"Veined steps of marble/purple, gold and green."
(not unlike the one that a young "Veronica" is seen praying the Rosary
to in the flashback sequence of the Music Video for "Veronica")
On the song LONG JOURNEY HOME, Costello virtually nicks the TUNE from a
traditional Catholic Hymn that he would have sung as an Altar Boy
growing up. The song is called "O Queen of the Holy Rosary" and note the
lyrics:
O Queen of the Holy Rosary,
O bless us as we pray,
And offer thee our roses
In garlands day by day,
While from our Father's garden,
With loving hearts and bold,
We gather to thine honor
Buds white and red and gold.
Compare the line in Long Journey Home:
"Red white and blue, green white and gold" to the same tune and you
have a virtual GLOSS on the Catholic Hymn.
Not to mention "Miss Mary"'s "Purple, Gold and Green" line.
Costello is a virtual treasure trove of Traditional Catholic influences
that at the very least INFORM his lyrics.
Yours in Christ,
Ursula!
- Mr. Average
- Posts: 2031
- Joined: Sat Jun 28, 2003 12:22 pm
- Location: Orange County, Californication
No. Not at all.selfmademug wrote:Is it me or does this seem life going through Beach Boys lyrcs and counting the references to cars?
I suppose that if you equate a car to an omniscient diety then you can justify this as a rather feeble attempt at humour.
Clearly, and regardless of Elvis' current position on a belief system in a Higher Power, he has been tremendously influenced by the cathechisms and teachings of the Faith of his upbringing. Somehow, I just think it too much of a stretch to believe that the man is a non-believer yet peppers his lyrics with a multitude of references to Faith constructs that live within the hearts, minds, and souls of believers.
Thanks, John. While I have always recognized these references, I would have never quessed how pervasive they are in his writing. This is eye-opening to me. Thanks again.
"The smarter mysteries are hidden in the light" - Jean Giono (1895-1970)
SMMM, your Beach Boys analogy is a good one.
I got some more: it's like going through early Springsteen and counting car/highway references, or looking for "mystical highways" in middle period Van, or looking for homoerotic imagery in Morrisey lyrics, or digging deep into the Difford lyric book in search of infidelity/drinking obsessions.
And since this is not a Pope RIP thread I hope I am not out of line in stating that the religious imagery in EC songs, I suspect, are just cultural, and indicative of a catholic upbringing, which, I also suspect, from personal experience, is one of the surest ways known to man to destroy religiosity. Nothing sacred in any of it, which is more than I can say for the references cited above, which I think were taken quite seriously by their makers (lyricists, that is).
I got some more: it's like going through early Springsteen and counting car/highway references, or looking for "mystical highways" in middle period Van, or looking for homoerotic imagery in Morrisey lyrics, or digging deep into the Difford lyric book in search of infidelity/drinking obsessions.
And since this is not a Pope RIP thread I hope I am not out of line in stating that the religious imagery in EC songs, I suspect, are just cultural, and indicative of a catholic upbringing, which, I also suspect, from personal experience, is one of the surest ways known to man to destroy religiosity. Nothing sacred in any of it, which is more than I can say for the references cited above, which I think were taken quite seriously by their makers (lyricists, that is).
- Who Shot Sam?
- Posts: 7097
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 5:05 pm
- Location: Somewhere in the distance
- Contact:
Jeez, lighten up man.Mr. Average wrote:No. Not at all.selfmademug wrote:Is it me or does this seem life going through Beach Boys lyrcs and counting the references to cars?
I suppose that if you equate a car to an omniscient diety then you can justify this as a rather feeble attempt at humour.
Mother, Moose-Hunter, Maverick
-
- Posts: 2228
- Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 2:20 pm
- Location: Poland
For goodness sake, do we have to turn it into another heated political/religious debate ?
John has forwarded some examples of Catholic/religious references/imagery in Elvis’ lyrics. Admittedly some are a bit forced, but they say a lot about his upbringing or cultural influences.
I remember we once scrutinized his lyrics for ‘tears’, ‘angel’ and ‘king’ references, which I suppose is a bit more pointless, yet nobody opposed.
At other times people are paying attention to Elvis’ undoubtedly leftist views expressed in lyrics, or his jibes at GWB in interviews or at gigs.
This is all part of Elvis, whether we agree with it or not, and I can’t see why Elvis’ fans could not be interested in „religious” references in his songs.
Keep ‘em coming, John.
Peace.
John has forwarded some examples of Catholic/religious references/imagery in Elvis’ lyrics. Admittedly some are a bit forced, but they say a lot about his upbringing or cultural influences.
I remember we once scrutinized his lyrics for ‘tears’, ‘angel’ and ‘king’ references, which I suppose is a bit more pointless, yet nobody opposed.
At other times people are paying attention to Elvis’ undoubtedly leftist views expressed in lyrics, or his jibes at GWB in interviews or at gigs.
This is all part of Elvis, whether we agree with it or not, and I can’t see why Elvis’ fans could not be interested in „religious” references in his songs.
Keep ‘em coming, John.
Peace.
If you don't know what is wrong with me
Then you don't know what you've missed
Then you don't know what you've missed
- so lacklustre
- Posts: 3183
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 2:36 pm
- Location: half way to bliss
-
- Posts: 2228
- Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 2:20 pm
- Location: Poland
- Mr. Average
- Posts: 2031
- Joined: Sat Jun 28, 2003 12:22 pm
- Location: Orange County, Californication
Amazing, WSS. What exactly warrants your comment to "lighten up"? If this is a censored forum, then so be it. But if a person expresses an opinion diametrically oppossed to your point of view, is the intelligent retort "lighten up"?
I have as much a right to post my opinion as anyone here.
And Alexv, next time you see SMM (wink wink), maybe a short discussion on posting platitudes to your own messages might be an interesting talking point.
"Mirror Mirroe on the wall..."
I suspect that WSS hasn't yet figured it out. Give it time.
Great post, John. Thank you. I find this thread captivating and the references are very interesting, providing new insight (for me) into this great lyricist and performer. And by the way, I was raised in a religious home, and constantly challenged to draw my own conclusions from the evidence-base born of Faith. My father was a scientist, and my mother an intellect, and while they laid a solid foundation of catechism and belief systems, they challenged me to constantly question my Faith. So, as a matter of fact, I do not beleive that Johns post(s) are equivalent to car analogies. And As funny as that line might be to many here, it was insulting to me, and I would think it may be insulting to others who have the courage to believe and serve.
I have as much a right to post my opinion as anyone here.
And Alexv, next time you see SMM (wink wink), maybe a short discussion on posting platitudes to your own messages might be an interesting talking point.
"Mirror Mirroe on the wall..."
I suspect that WSS hasn't yet figured it out. Give it time.
Great post, John. Thank you. I find this thread captivating and the references are very interesting, providing new insight (for me) into this great lyricist and performer. And by the way, I was raised in a religious home, and constantly challenged to draw my own conclusions from the evidence-base born of Faith. My father was a scientist, and my mother an intellect, and while they laid a solid foundation of catechism and belief systems, they challenged me to constantly question my Faith. So, as a matter of fact, I do not beleive that Johns post(s) are equivalent to car analogies. And As funny as that line might be to many here, it was insulting to me, and I would think it may be insulting to others who have the courage to believe and serve.
"The smarter mysteries are hidden in the light" - Jean Giono (1895-1970)
Thanks JF. I had noticed the cat. refs but not realised they were so numerous. Now that would form the basis of a good chapter in a bio.
The one I prefer is "In a certain way he felt like Jesus". It's not particularly Catholic, but arguably the most Christian of them all.
(You may throw all the dogmas overboard, which I do - but I don't think it's important -, you may have no faith, but you read that verse and, there are no words, I guess it nails you...)
The one I prefer is "In a certain way he felt like Jesus". It's not particularly Catholic, but arguably the most Christian of them all.
(You may throw all the dogmas overboard, which I do - but I don't think it's important -, you may have no faith, but you read that verse and, there are no words, I guess it nails you...)
Happy Thanksgiving, fellow celebrants!!
Here I am doing a post-pandrial check of my favorite waste of time (that's a Marshall Cranshaw reference, by the way) and I must confess, Mr. A., that I have no idea what the heck you are talking about.
Indulge me: what's with the "next time you see SMM (wink, wink)"? Are you doing an Eric Idle bit? And what's with your suggestion that when we meet "a short discussion on posting platitudes" should ensue? I've only met one person on this board, the estimable Shatterproof whose kindness allowed me to check out our Hero at Lincoln Center last summer. Merci Shatterproof.
But enough about me, let's talk about you. I think WSS was perfectly right to tell you to lighten up (no need to thank me, WSS, wink, wink) because until you piped in there was no angst in this thread, just lots of religious references, and a lightherted reference to how EC is not the only artist to fill his lyrics with repeatedly used images. Nobody was equating cars, or highways, or homoerotic imagery, or drinking obsessions to an "omniscient deity". Nothing in the comments posted by John could lead a reasonable person to conclude that EC's references had to be interpreted in relation to an "ominiscient deity". They are just religious images, for goodness sakes. Lots of people use religious images without signifying some kind of transcendental concern with an "omniscient deity". I say "Bless you" when people sneeze; I say "jesus" when pissed off; I say "honey, you are an angel" when my secretary brings me a Latte without my asking, etc. etc. I would bet you that if someone followed me around for a couple of years, coypying down all my "religious" references they would conclude that my life is postively biblical. Trust me, it's nothing of the kind. That "omniscient deity" crack was yours, and was clearly intended to start a fight, which is why WSS told you to lighten up.
Here I am doing a post-pandrial check of my favorite waste of time (that's a Marshall Cranshaw reference, by the way) and I must confess, Mr. A., that I have no idea what the heck you are talking about.
Indulge me: what's with the "next time you see SMM (wink, wink)"? Are you doing an Eric Idle bit? And what's with your suggestion that when we meet "a short discussion on posting platitudes" should ensue? I've only met one person on this board, the estimable Shatterproof whose kindness allowed me to check out our Hero at Lincoln Center last summer. Merci Shatterproof.
But enough about me, let's talk about you. I think WSS was perfectly right to tell you to lighten up (no need to thank me, WSS, wink, wink) because until you piped in there was no angst in this thread, just lots of religious references, and a lightherted reference to how EC is not the only artist to fill his lyrics with repeatedly used images. Nobody was equating cars, or highways, or homoerotic imagery, or drinking obsessions to an "omniscient deity". Nothing in the comments posted by John could lead a reasonable person to conclude that EC's references had to be interpreted in relation to an "ominiscient deity". They are just religious images, for goodness sakes. Lots of people use religious images without signifying some kind of transcendental concern with an "omniscient deity". I say "Bless you" when people sneeze; I say "jesus" when pissed off; I say "honey, you are an angel" when my secretary brings me a Latte without my asking, etc. etc. I would bet you that if someone followed me around for a couple of years, coypying down all my "religious" references they would conclude that my life is postively biblical. Trust me, it's nothing of the kind. That "omniscient deity" crack was yours, and was clearly intended to start a fight, which is why WSS told you to lighten up.
- Who Shot Sam?
- Posts: 7097
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 5:05 pm
- Location: Somewhere in the distance
- Contact:
What in the world are you talking about? Have you been raiding the liquor cabinet?Mr. Average wrote:Amazing, WSS. What exactly warrants your comment to "lighten up"? If this is a censored forum, then so be it. But if a person expresses an opinion diametrically oppossed to your point of view, is the intelligent retort "lighten up"?
I have as much a right to post my opinion as anyone here.
And Alexv, next time you see SMM (wink wink), maybe a short discussion on posting platitudes to your own messages might be an interesting talking point.
"Mirror Mirroe on the wall..."
I suspect that WSS hasn't yet figured it out. Give it time.
Great post, John. Thank you. I find this thread captivating and the references are very interesting, providing new insight (for me) into this great lyricist and performer. And by the way, I was raised in a religious home, and constantly challenged to draw my own conclusions from the evidence-base born of Faith. My father was a scientist, and my mother an intellect, and while they laid a solid foundation of catechism and belief systems, they challenged me to constantly question my Faith. So, as a matter of fact, I do not beleive that Johns post(s) are equivalent to car analogies. And As funny as that line might be to many here, it was insulting to me, and I would think it may be insulting to others who have the courage to believe and serve.
She didn't say that automobiles and God were equivalent, you half-wit. She said that spotting references to religion in EC's songs was about as easy as spotting car references in Beach Boys' tunes - and it is. How you could find that insulting is beyond me.
You have every right to post your opinions on here and I have every right to ignore them, which is what I intend to do from now on.
I've got another thing to be thankful for today, but I'm not telling you what it is.
Mother, Moose-Hunter, Maverick
Exactly. Having been raised a Catholic, it's the very water he swims in (me, too, believer or no) and so pointing out every instance of such references seems silly to ME.alexv wrote: I got some more: it's like going through early Springsteen and counting car/highway references, or looking for "mystical highways" in middle period Van, or looking for homoerotic imagery in Morrisey lyrics, or digging deep into the Difford lyric book in search of infidelity/drinking obsessions.
I'm quite interested in and drawn to Catholic artists and their output, since it's a moral perspective I understand very well, and a set of values about which I have strongly ambivalent feelings. Waugh's Brideshead Revisited is probably my favorite novel, and although it's about many things, first and foremost it's about Catholicism. Whether he's a believer or not, and I suspect he is to a larger extent than I am, Elvis doesn't lay out any personal belief system the way Waugh does, however (I suspect that's very personal); it's more a worldview, and I don't see the challenge or interest in pointing out every reference to it.
It has been written elsewhere on the board that it's futile to teach pigs to sing. Myself, I have faith in those smart animals. However, getting self-important blowhards to stop seeing things as personal insults against their own perceived superiority, well THAT is futile.
PS, for the record, I am *not* Alexv! I am Alex C.
I'm sure the centrist lawyer Alexv will find it amusing to learn that he's the same person as the somewhat left-of-center, so-NOT-a-lawyer (sadly for my bank balance) heart-on-sleeve single mom from Massachusetts by way of New Jersey.
Occasionally pathos spills over into hilarity!.... life's so amusing.
I'm sure the centrist lawyer Alexv will find it amusing to learn that he's the same person as the somewhat left-of-center, so-NOT-a-lawyer (sadly for my bank balance) heart-on-sleeve single mom from Massachusetts by way of New Jersey.
Occasionally pathos spills over into hilarity!.... life's so amusing.
- Otis Westinghouse
- Posts: 8856
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 3:32 pm
- Location: The theatre of dreams
I feel you, Alex the femme.
But my anal legal instincts led me to search my posting record to see how often the two of us have lobbed "platitudes" at one another and, listen, let's agree to disagree once in a while.
As you know, I think Springsteen is a lazy, no good phony, McCartney is over the hill, Fidel is a modern day Stalin, the Pope's memory should be respected, Pedro Luis Ferrer made the best record released in 2005, Elvis once in a while writes shitty lyrics and is more "careerist" than he lets on, the war in Iraq is not completely indefensible, Michael Moore is an asshole, WIWC is the only truly awful EC record, and "Happiness" is a disturbing piece of movie crap. What do you think?
But my anal legal instincts led me to search my posting record to see how often the two of us have lobbed "platitudes" at one another and, listen, let's agree to disagree once in a while.
As you know, I think Springsteen is a lazy, no good phony, McCartney is over the hill, Fidel is a modern day Stalin, the Pope's memory should be respected, Pedro Luis Ferrer made the best record released in 2005, Elvis once in a while writes shitty lyrics and is more "careerist" than he lets on, the war in Iraq is not completely indefensible, Michael Moore is an asshole, WIWC is the only truly awful EC record, and "Happiness" is a disturbing piece of movie crap. What do you think?
Excuse me?!?alexv wrote:I feel you, Alex the femme.
I think we're already there! I think Springsteen is amazing, talented and courageous, even if the quality of his output is varied, and I'd say more or less the same of Elvis and McCartney. I quite like WIWC; I think Castro is largely horrible and has outlived his usefulness by at least 30 years but that to compare him to Stalin is nearly obscene; and I think Michael Moore needs to be careful if he wants to keep his credibility, which in my opinion is mostly warranted. I think the war in Iraq as conceived, initiated and fought is wholly indefensible, but I find the peace movement mostly bankrupt of any useful ideas these days. Generally I despair of us being able to be part of the solution and not part of the problem at this point but I'm still engaged and participating in our own democracy in the hope that things can be otherwise. I know nothing of Pedro Luis Ferrer and have not seen 'Happiness'.alexv wrote:But my anal legal instincts led me to search my posting record to see how often the two of us have lobbed "platitudes" at one another and, listen, let's agree to disagree once in a while.
I suppose if we were really the same person it would be amusing to think of 'our' posts as feigned replies to each other.
- Otis Westinghouse
- Posts: 8856
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 3:32 pm
- Location: The theatre of dreams
- Boy With A Problem
- Posts: 2718
- Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2003 9:41 pm
- Location: Inside the Pocket of a Clown
Alexv wrote:
- AgreeI think Springsteen is a lazy, no good phony
- AgreeMcCartney is over the hill
- Stalin killed millions - no systematic genocide in Cuba - DisagreeFidel is a modern day Stalin
- Disagree - he may just burn in hell for all eternity over the way he handled the child rape scandal in his churchthe Pope's memory should be respected
- I really like the Eugene Kelly record that nobody ever mentions - I don't know Pedro Luis Ferrer, but Jose Ferrer had an incredible voicePedro Luis Ferrer made the best record released in 2005
- AgreeElvis once in a while writes shitty lyrics and is more "careerist" than he lets on
Disagreethe war in Iraq is not completely indefensible
- He might be, but his films are brilliantMichael Moore is an asshole
- A couple of good songsWIWC is the only truly awful EC record
- Not familiar with it"Happiness" is a disturbing piece of movie crap
Everyone just needs to fuckin’ relax. Smoke more weed, the world is ending.
- mood swung
- Posts: 6908
- Joined: Thu Jun 05, 2003 3:59 pm
- Location: out looking for my tribe
- Contact: